November 19, 2026
In the summer of 2021, two buyers bought waterfront land on San Marco Island, the second island east of downtown Miami along the Venetian Causeway. One spent $48.5 million across June and July 2021 to put together a 1.2-acre assemblage at 1230 and 1236 South Venetian Way, according to The Real Deal. That same year, Brooklyn-based Maven Construction paid $6 million for one 0.3-acre lot a short distance away at 1413 North Venetian Way.
Five years later, both stories have ended. The assemblage went back to market as four separate parcels and sold for $40.8 million in total, at least $7.7 million below its cost. The single lot came back as a finished house and sold this fall for $48.5 million, the highest price ever paid for a home on the Venetian Islands.
So one buyer spent $48.5 million and lost money, and the other sold a home for $48.5 million and set a record. The difference came from what the Venetian Islands market pays for: a finished house on a lot of about a third of an acre with roughly 100 feet of water. Buyers have paid well for that combination. Land beyond it has not earned back its cost.
The plan for the assemblage was one large estate with a tennis court, listing agent Julian Johnston of the Corcoran Group told The Real Deal. Pandemic delays held up construction, and the property was on and off the market for years, at asking prices as high as $65 million for a planned spec mansion. One 0.3-acre piece of it, 1230 South Venetian Way, had about 100 feet of water frontage and was asking $11 million in 2024. The Real Deal reported then that it had been on and off the market since 2022.
What eventually sold the land was making it smaller. Johnston advised splitting the assemblage into 0.3-acre parcels, "more in line with the average lot size in the Venetian Islands," and said buyers who wanted larger lots were choosing North Bay Road over South Venetian Way. "People don't always want to be the most expensive house on the block," he told The Real Deal.
After the split, the four parcels sold one at a time. 1224 South Venetian Way went for $8 million in January 2025, 1228 for $10.3 million, 1230 for $11 million and 1236 for $11.5 million. That averages about $10.2 million for a standard San Marco waterfront lot sold as vacant land between January 2025 and spring 2026.
Maven Construction's lot at 1413 North Venetian Way is the same size, 0.3 acre, with 103 feet of water frontage. It faces north onto the Intracoastal with open-water and Miami skyline views, Mansion Global reported. The owners built a 10,689-square-foot house there named Forte. It has seven bedrooms, glass curtain walls, a three-tiered green roof, a 70-foot pool, a subterranean 10-car garage, a 14-foot seawall and a deep-water dock with a boat lift. The Real Deal lists an 8,000-square-foot understory beneath it and a 30,000-pound lift.
The pricing went the way it usually does at the top of this market. The house first listed in December at $60 million and took several price cuts. It went under contract in late September 2026 at an asking price of $47.5 million, or $4,444 a square foot. It then closed at $48.5 million, or $4,530 a square foot, which was above that final asking price. The previous island record was the $46 million sale of a home at 55 East San Marino Drive in July 2025, also on a half-acre-or-smaller footprint with 160 feet of water.
Compare the two outcomes. The vacant lots on South Venetian Way averaged about $10.2 million. A lot of the same size on North Venetian Way, with a finished house on it, sold for nearly five times that. Nearly all of the extra value came from the house.
The houses on either side of 1413 show the same pattern at smaller scale.
| Address | House | Status and price | Earlier purchase |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1413 North Venetian Way | 10,689 sq ft, completed 2026 | Sold for $48.5M, fall 2026 | $6M, 2021 |
| 1417 North Venetian Way | 7,600 sq ft, built 2023 | Sold for $27.5M, April 2026 | $23.9M, 2024 |
| 1421 North Venetian Way | 4,170 sq ft, built 1938 | Under contract at a $16.9M asking price, September 2026 | $4.1M, 2013 |
These three houses share a street, an exposure and a view, and their prices still differ by about $31.6 million. 1421 has a 1938 house on 0.3 acre with 105 feet of water, about the same as the other two lots. Its $16.9 million asking price is mostly for the land and the location on that stretch of North Venetian Way. The 2023 house at 1417 returned to market in February 2026 at just under $28 million and sold that April for $27.5 million. At the top of the block is the new 10,689-square-foot house. Along this block, the price goes up as the house gets larger and newer, and the lots are nearly identical.
A few doors west, 1369 North Venetian Way follows the same pattern. It is a spec house finished in 2023, 6,500 square feet on a quarter acre with a pool and dock, and it sold to hospitality executive Nick Patel for $19.4 million, The Real Deal reported in February 2025. Back on the island's other street, 1041 North Venetian Drive sold in March 2026 for $17.3 million. It is a 6,500-square-foot house on a 9,000-square-foot lot that its developer, Humberto Ramirez, finished late last year, and The Real Deal reported it is on the same island as 1230 South Venetian Way. It sold within three months of listing, and Ramirez told The Real Deal that buyers at that price "know exactly what they want."
The other islands priced the standard lot the same way. Di Lido Island in Miami Beach is the clearest example from the past two years. In 2018, Daniel Lewis bought a 0.3-acre site at 845 East Di Lido Drive for $5.9 million. He built a 6,100-square-foot spec house with 106 feet of water frontage, completed it in 2024 and sold it for $19.5 million, according to The Real Deal.
A double-size site on the same island did less well. The half-acre at 228 and 302 West Dilido Drive came with 120 feet of water and approved plans for an 11,000-square-foot SAOTA-designed house. The owner bought it for $15.2 million in 2020 and listed it at $28 million, then cut the price to $27 million. It sold in March 2026 for $24.5 million. That was a gain for the seller but below the asking price, even with permits included. The Real Deal's March report on the sale described land prices as recovering and demand as strongest for turnkey waterfront houses.
Older houses are also selling below their asking prices. 1001 North Venetian Drive is a five-bedroom 1938 house on a 0.3-acre lot. It last asked $12.9 million and sold in March 2026 for $10.5 million, about 19 percent less. The seller had paid $6.2 million for it in 2021. Owners have still made money, and buyers have still negotiated.
These sales point to a practical way to read a listing on the causeway. Start with the lot. A third of an acre with about 100 feet of water is the standard unit here. San Marco's vacant lots sold for $8 million to $11.5 million between January 2025 and spring 2026, which gives a reference point for the land under any house you look at. Whatever the asking price is above that figure is the price of the house. The block of North Venetian Way shows how much that amount depends on the house's age and size.
Extra land on these islands has not brought an extra price in proportion. A buyer who wants more than a standard lot is paying for something the buyers of the past two years have chosen not to pay a premium for, and those buyers would also be the eventual resale market. The South Venetian Way parcels sold once they were back to the standard size.
Asking prices have bent as well. In 2026, the record house sold after its price fell from $60 million, the Di Lido double lot sold below its reduced price, and an older house on North Venetian Drive sold 19 percent under asking. When the house matched what buyers wanted, as at 1041 North Venetian Drive and at 1413 North Venetian Way's final price, homes still sold quickly and at full value. Our Venetian Islands neighborhood guide has more on the island chain. For the same land-versus-house question one causeway north, see our post on why a teardown and a new house sell for the same price on Sunset Islands.
Is San Marco Island in Miami or Miami Beach? Biscayne Island and San Marco Island, the two westernmost Venetian Islands, are in the City of Miami, the Miami Herald has reported. San Marino, Di Lido, Rivo Alto and Belle Isle are in Miami Beach.
What is the current price record on the Venetian Islands? The record is $48.5 million, paid this fall for 1413 North Venetian Way on San Marco Island. It replaced the $46 million record set on San Marino Island in July 2025.
What did a vacant waterfront lot sell for on San Marco recently? The four 0.3-acre parcels on South Venetian Way sold for between $8 million and $11.5 million from January 2025 through spring 2026.
If you are weighing a house on North Venetian Way against a lot on South Venetian Way, or comparing one island's frontage with another's, the team at Gilles Rais Fine Homes would welcome the conversation before you make an offer. Request a Private Consultation, or start with a confidential valuation if you already own on the causeway.
CEO Founder
With a career spanning over 25 years in the community and 16 years as a Real Estate Agent, Gilles has amassed a wealth of market knowledge that is second to none. He has his finger on the pulse of the industry, always staying one step ahead of the game and ensuring that his clients have the upper hand in every transaction.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
The Gilles Rais Fine Homes Team are dedicated to helping you find your dream home and assisting with any selling needs you may have. Contact us today to start your home searching journey!